UIN Jakarta Researchers Recommend Reformulating Religious Moderation Education
Jakarta, UIN Online News – Researchers from Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University (UIN) Jakarta have recommended that Indonesia’s State Islamic Religious Universities (PTKIN) evaluate and reformulate their approaches to teaching tolerance and religious moderation on campus. The recommendation is based on research findings indicating that socioeconomic factors and institutional dynamics are more significantly associated with students’ religious tolerance than their individual levels of religiosity.
This is the central finding of a study by UIN Jakarta researchers published in an article titled “The Influence of Socioeconomic Factors and Religiosity on Religious Tolerance Among Students at Indonesian Islamic Higher Education Institutions” in Jurnal Pendidikan Islam. The researchers were Zulkifli, Rena Latifa, Muhamad Fahri, and Sholikatus Sa’diyah. The study was supported by an institutional research grant for the 2020 fiscal year.
The findings offer a new perspective on developing religious moderation education in higher education. They indicate that the intensity of an individual’s religiosity cannot automatically be used to predict their level of tolerance toward people from different religious or Islamic school-of-thought backgrounds.
Based on their findings, the researchers recommend that tolerance education at PTKIN institutions go beyond strengthening doctrinal understanding and theological knowledge. It should also focus on fostering inclusive social experiences, critical thinking skills, and openness to differences.
Challenges of Religious Moderation Education in Higher Education
Tolerance and religious moderation education have become important issues in Indonesia, a society characterized by religious, cultural, and theological diversity. These challenges are becoming increasingly complex amid the growth of digital media, globalization, and the transmission of transnational religious ideologies, all of which influence the religious outlook of younger generations.
In this context, PTKIN students hold a strategic position as future intellectuals, educators, and community leaders. Strengthening tolerance on campus is not only related to student character development but also contributes to the sustainability of life in a pluralistic society.
Several findings cited in the study point to changing religious attitudes among younger generations. A 2019 study by the Setara Institute recorded a tendency toward conservative and formalistic religiosity among students at Islamic religious colleges. Meanwhile, research by the Center for the Study of Islam and Society (PPIM) at UIN Jakarta found that 58.8 percent of young Muslims held religious attitudes that tended to be radical, even though their daily behavior was generally moderate.
Meanwhile, the Religious Harmony Index released by the Ministry of Religious Affairs shows that the tolerance dimension consistently ranks lower than the equality and cooperation dimensions.
These conditions indicate that religious harmony cannot be measured solely by the presence of harmonious social relationships. It must also be assessed by individuals’ willingness to accept differences in beliefs, perspectives, and religious practices.
Examining the Factors That Shape Student Tolerance
The study sought to answer two main questions. First, can individual religiosity, gender, involvement in student organizations, parental income, and allowance levels collectively predict religious tolerance among PTKIN students?
Second, to what extent does each of these variables independently influence religious tolerance when the other variables are controlled for?
To answer these questions, the research team used a quantitative approach that integrated perspectives from the psychology of religion and sociology. Religiosity and religious tolerance were measured using instruments whose construct validity was first tested through Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA).
The religiosity scale was adapted from the Centrality of Religiosity Scale (CRS), which covers five dimensions: intellectual, ideological, public religious practice, private religious practice, and religious experience.
Religious tolerance was measured using instruments developed by Putnam and Campbell (2012), Hook and colleagues (2017), and Ardi and colleagues (2021). The instrument consists of eight items measuring relational and intellectual dimensions of tolerance, both between religious communities and between groups or schools of thought within Islam.
The CFA results showed that the instruments met the validity criteria after modifications were made to the measurement model. All items in both scales were found to be statistically valid.
Socioeconomic Factors Show Greater Significance
Descriptive analysis showed that most PTKIN students fell into the moderate categories for both religiosity and religious tolerance.
A total of 57.3 percent of students had a moderate level of religiosity, 18.7 percent had a low level, and 24 percent had a high level. Religious tolerance was also predominantly moderate, at 67 percent, while 16.7 percent of students fell into the low category and 16.3 percent into the high category.
In the multiple regression analysis, the five variables tested simultaneously were statistically significant in predicting students’ religious tolerance. However, partial testing showed that not all variables had a significant effect.
Of the five variables, parental income, gender, and involvement in student organizations were found to have significant associations with religious tolerance. Individual religiosity and allowance levels, on the other hand, did not show statistically significant effects.
Parental income had a positive coefficient of 2.953, with a significance value of 0.001. This finding indicates a positive association between parental income and students’ religious tolerance within the research model.
Gender had a coefficient of -2.948, with a significance value of less than 0.001. Involvement in student organizations had a coefficient of -0.300, with a significance value of 0.030.
By contrast, individual religiosity had a significance value of 0.571, while allowance levels had a significance value of 0.959. Neither variable was found to have a statistically significant partial effect in the tested model.
Nevertheless, the researchers cautioned that these results should be interpreted carefully. The research model had a coefficient of determination of 5.7 percent, meaning that the five variables explained only a small proportion of the variation in students’ religious tolerance.
Thus, 94.3 percent of the variation in religious tolerance remained unexplained by the model and may be associated with factors beyond the variables examined.
Religiosity Does Not Automatically Lead to Tolerance
The lack of a statistically significant effect of individual religiosity was one of the study’s key findings. The result challenges the assumption that the higher a person’s level of religiosity, the greater their tolerance toward groups with different beliefs.
The researchers explained that religiosity is not a single-dimensional construct. In the psychology of religion, religiosity can have different motivational orientations, including intrinsic, extrinsic, and quest orientations, the latter referring to an open-ended search for truth.
Intrinsic religiosity involves experiencing religion as an end in itself, while extrinsic religiosity views religion as a means of gaining social benefits or status. The quest orientation emphasizes openness to searching, questioning, and developing a broader understanding.
These different orientations may lead religiosity to produce diverse social attitudes. When religiosity is measured in general terms, different orientations may even offset one another in statistical analysis.
The findings also show that the intensity of religious practice does not necessarily correspond to cognitive flexibility. Tolerance is not simply a matter of how strongly someone observes religious rituals. It also involves the ability to understand differences, develop intellectual humility, and accept the possibility of other perspectives.
Student Organizations Should Encourage Inclusive Interaction
The study also found a significant negative association between involvement in student organizations and religious tolerance. This finding can be explained through Social Identity Theory, which emphasizes the formation of group identities, or in-groups.
Participation in organizations can strengthen solidarity and social bonds among members. However, under certain conditions, overly strong internal ties may limit interaction with groups outside the organization, or out-groups.
The researchers linked this possibility to tendencies toward doctrinal homogeneity and the reinforcement of group identity in some student organization environments.
Nevertheless, the findings should not be interpreted to mean that student organizations in general cause intolerance. Rather, they provide an opportunity for campus administrators to evaluate how student organizations build social interactions, manage differences, and develop programs that are open to other groups.
Meanwhile, the positive association between parental income and religious tolerance may be explained through Intergroup Contact Theory and the concept of social capital. Better socioeconomic conditions may provide greater access to mobility, broader social networks, and opportunities to interact with diverse communities.
However, this explanation is a theoretical interpretation of the research findings, not direct evidence that parental income causes an increase in religious tolerance.
Three Recommendations for PTKIN Institutions
Based on their findings, the researchers recommend three strategic steps for PTKIN institutions to develop tolerance education and religious moderation.
First, expand sustained interaction across groups through cross-group contact activities, interfaith dialogue, and dialogue between different Islamic schools of thought. These programs should be designed to give students direct opportunities to interact with people from different backgrounds, perspectives, and beliefs.
Second, integrate ethical reasoning and critical thinking into the learning process. Students should be equipped to assess religious and social issues through reasoned argument, understand their context, and avoid judgments based on prejudice toward other groups.
Third, foster a campus environment that encourages intellectual humility and inclusive openness. Student organizations, academic activities, and campus development programs can be directed toward creating spaces for meaningful interaction that strengthen solidarity without fostering group exclusivity.
These recommendations emphasize that religious moderation education needs to move beyond an approach focused solely on strengthening religious knowledge. It should also take into account social experiences, the quality of thinking, and student character development.
Creating Opportunities for Further Research
The researchers also emphasized that the study’s findings should be developed through further research. The low coefficient of determination indicates that religious tolerance is a complex phenomenon that cannot be explained solely by demographic, socioeconomic, and general religiosity factors.
Future studies are encouraged to include psychological variables, such as personality types and cognitive styles, as well as direct intercultural contact experiences. Campus cultural climate and exposure to political discourse through digital media may also be important factors to investigate.
Expanding the scope of research is also necessary to compare PTKIN students with students at public universities and members of other religious communities. This would help develop a more comprehensive understanding of the factors that shape tolerance.
Thus, the study not only provides an overview of factors associated with students’ religious tolerance but also serves as a basis for developing more context-sensitive policies for religious moderation education.
For PTKIN institutions, the study’s main message is that fostering tolerance cannot be achieved solely by increasing theological understanding or the intensity of ritual practice. Religious moderation education must be accompanied by inclusive social experiences, critical thinking skills, and a campus environment that provides space for differences.
Through this approach, PTKIN institutions are expected to strengthen their role as educational institutions that produce graduates who are not only knowledgeable and religious but also capable of living together fairly, openly, and responsibly in a diverse society.
(Mahardhika Research Team, Information and Public Relations Center, LP2M UIN Jakarta / Fauziah Muslimah / Keisha)
